Today at AiT/Planet Lar

Subscribe to the site feed.

August 10, 2005
permalink

Listen to the sound of thinking: "It's not about agreeing or disagreeing -- opinion isn't really the point of criticism, although that's what everybody takes away from it -- it's about watching a thesis being developed, about watching an idea being defended."

That's not me, online comics reviewers, that's award-winning writer and essayist Jon Carroll, and, unless you're Harlan Ellison, Carroll's a better writer than you, so pay attention to what he writes. No one cares about your opinion; people care about how well your idea of things are outlined and defended. So, all you guys emailing me in high dudgeon, offended by one parenthetical paragraph in what's ostensibly a review of Dukes of Hazzard, with all of your impassioned defenses of past reviews (parenthetically, again, I note that only one of the six of you who wrote to me yesterday was the guy I was talking about, so all of the rest of you have guilty consciences) need to defend your ideas within the body of your reviews and not contained in frenzied albeit well-intentioned emails to me. In that vein, here's some more cheap shots and bon mots from around the Internet:

First up: we've finally made an honest woman out of Josh Richardson.

Jason Richards opened up Riot! today, and posted up a pic of the color key and original art pages I sent him to congratulate him on his new shop. We'll be hearing more about his shop in the future.

Greg from Comics Should Be Good loves The Annotated Mantooth. But, honestly, who doesn't? Communists, that's who.

You can meet the booze-addled malcontents behind last year's World Series at Comicopia this Friday in Boston, as reported by my friend and yours Brad Searles: "The two gents behind the best Red Sox fan blog out there, Surviving Grady, will be stopping by the best comic store out there, Comicopia in Kenmore Square, this Friday night from 6-7pm (then heading to the game, 'natch). They'll be signing copies of their every-fan-should-own-it collection of Red Sox writings that AiT/Planet Lar recently released. It's perfectly captures the entirety of last year's spectacular season, all the ups and downs and ups and big-time downs and unbelievable ups from a couple obsessed points of view. Loved it. So catch 'em Friday night, or on Sunday, August 28th from 1-2pm and 5-7pm (unless the game goes long, of course)."


28 December 2003 | 04 January 2004 | 11 January 2004 | 18 January 2004 | 25 January 2004 | 01 February 2004 | 08 February 2004 | 15 February 2004 | 22 February 2004 | 29 February 2004 | 07 March 2004 | 14 March 2004 | 21 March 2004 | 28 March 2004 | 04 April 2004 | 11 April 2004 | 18 April 2004 | 25 April 2004 | 02 May 2004 | 09 May 2004 | 16 May 2004 | 23 May 2004 | 30 May 2004 | 06 June 2004 | 13 June 2004 | 20 June 2004 | 27 June 2004 | 04 July 2004 | 11 July 2004 | 18 July 2004 | 25 July 2004 | 01 August 2004 | 08 August 2004 | 15 August 2004 | 22 August 2004 | 29 August 2004 | 05 September 2004 | 12 September 2004 | 19 September 2004 | 26 September 2004 | 10 October 2004 | 17 October 2004 | 24 October 2004 | 31 October 2004 | 07 November 2004 | 14 November 2004 | 21 November 2004 | 28 November 2004 | 05 December 2004 | 12 December 2004 | 19 December 2004 | 26 December 2004 | 02 January 2005 | 09 January 2005 | 16 January 2005 | 23 January 2005 | 30 January 2005 | 06 February 2005 | 13 February 2005 | 20 February 2005 | 27 February 2005 | 06 March 2005 | 13 March 2005 | 20 March 2005 | 27 March 2005 | 03 April 2005 | 10 April 2005 | 17 April 2005 | 24 April 2005 | 01 May 2005 | 08 May 2005 | 15 May 2005 | 22 May 2005 | 29 May 2005 | 05 June 2005 | 19 June 2005 | 26 June 2005 | 03 July 2005 | 10 July 2005 | 17 July 2005 | 24 July 2005 | 31 July 2005 | 07 August 2005 | 14 August 2005 | 21 August 2005 | 28 August 2005 | 04 September 2005 | 11 September 2005 | 18 September 2005 | 25 September 2005 | 02 October 2005 | 09 October 2005 | 16 October 2005 | 23 October 2005 | 30 October 2005 | 06 November 2005 | 13 November 2005 | 20 November 2005 | 27 November 2005 | 04 December 2005 | 11 December 2005 | 18 December 2005 | 25 December 2005 | 01 January 2006 | 08 January 2006 | 15 January 2006 | 22 January 2006 | 29 January 2006 | 05 February 2006 | 12 February 2006 | 19 February 2006 | 26 February 2006 | 05 March 2006 | 12 March 2006 | 19 March 2006 | 26 March 2006 | 02 April 2006 | 09 April 2006 | 16 April 2006 | 23 April 2006 | 30 April 2006 | 07 May 2006 | 14 May 2006 | 21 May 2006 | 28 May 2006 | 04 June 2006 | 11 June 2006 | 18 June 2006 | 25 June 2006 | 02 July 2006 | 09 July 2006 | 23 July 2006 | 30 July 2006 | 06 August 2006 | 13 August 2006 | 20 August 2006 | 27 August 2006 | 03 September 2006 | 10 September 2006 | 17 September 2006 | 24 September 2006 | 22 October 2006 | 29 October 2006 | 05 November 2006 | 12 November 2006 | 19 November 2006 | 26 November 2006 | 03 December 2006 | 10 December 2006 | 17 December 2006 | 24 December 2006 | 31 December 2006 | 07 January 2007 | 14 January 2007 | 21 January 2007 | 28 January 2007 | 04 February 2007 | 11 February 2007 | 18 February 2007 | 25 February 2007 | 04 March 2007 | 11 March 2007 | 18 March 2007 | 25 March 2007 | 01 April 2007 | 08 April 2007 | 15 April 2007 | 22 April 2007 | 29 April 2007 | 06 May 2007 | 13 May 2007 | 20 May 2007 | 27 May 2007 | 03 June 2007 | 10 June 2007 | 17 June 2007 | 24 June 2007 | 01 July 2007 | 08 July 2007 | 15 July 2007 | 22 July 2007 | 05 August 2007 | 12 August 2007 | 19 August 2007 | 26 August 2007 | 02 September 2007 | 09 September 2007 | 16 September 2007 | 23 September 2007 | 30 September 2007 | 07 October 2007 | 14 October 2007 | 21 October 2007 | 28 October 2007 | 04 November 2007 | 11 November 2007 | 18 November 2007 | 25 November 2007 | 02 December 2007 | 09 December 2007 | 16 December 2007 | 23 December 2007 | 30 December 2007 | 06 January 2008 | 13 January 2008 | 20 January 2008 | 27 January 2008 |


Find any AiT/Planet Lar publication at your nearest comic store.

Can't find it at your local retailer? Get it online at Khepri.com