Today at AiT/Planet Lar

Subscribe to the site feed.

March 30, 2005
permalink

I watched this interesting thing on Discovery Channel Sunday night, explaining the Oracle at Delphi. Apparently, an archaeologist and a geologist were studying in the same area and were introduced by a mutual friend. Out at dinner one night, the geologist told his new buddy that he wished he could have been with him on his explorations and have seen the fault lines under Delphi. The archaelologist called bullshit as then-current thought held Delphi to be stable. Having drunk a lot of wine, the two argued until the geologist said, "Would you know a fault line if you saw one?" and the archaeologist had to admit that he would not.

Instead of being a baby and belly-aching all over the Internet about how he was "mean" to him, the archaelologist teamed up with the geologist and not only rewrote two hundred years of archaeology but actually determined the manner and cause of the effects in the temple as ancient history records. Not only was there a fault under the temple, but it released ethylene gas which accounted for the euphoria and muscle spasms some experienced when getting prophesied to. It also revealed why they closed up shop in 342 AD: not because of the rise of Christianity, but because there was a small tremor which closed the fault and the gas vented somewhere else.

So an ancient mystery was solved by two drunken jerks having an argument. But their disagreement was a rational, dispassionate one.

That's what some comic book commentators (I can't bring myself to write "critics") don't understand about discourse: that every disagreement doesn't have to be an emotionally-fuelled one.

For example, I had occasion to write this in response to my new pal Greg Burgas's "Am I now Larry Young's bitch?" on Comics Should Be Good: "I don't consider anyone my bitch. If anything, I think it's a little sad that there seems to be a faction of the blogospheriverse that seems to think that getting review copies in the mail from a publishing house of long-standing seems to equal some sort of bribe on my personal behalf.

"Like 'em, don't like 'em; the company doesn't care. If you're getting a review copy of our work, it's because we already respect your opinion or we think we might.

"Whether I have an 'online persona' or not is something I've sort of tired talking about, but the upshot is this: I have a unique personal cultural background and ability to express myself in written English. This may or may not jibe with an individual audience member's culture or ability to parse meaning from my outreach. Is that a 'persona'? Me, I just think people don't always understand each other. Whaddaya gonna do?"

Take out the emotionally-cued responses to a message board posting that makes you upset, and take a minute to read the words. Sometimes, we might just all learn something... like on This Very Special Episode of the AiT Daily Update.


28 December 2003 | 04 January 2004 | 11 January 2004 | 18 January 2004 | 25 January 2004 | 01 February 2004 | 08 February 2004 | 15 February 2004 | 22 February 2004 | 29 February 2004 | 07 March 2004 | 14 March 2004 | 21 March 2004 | 28 March 2004 | 04 April 2004 | 11 April 2004 | 18 April 2004 | 25 April 2004 | 02 May 2004 | 09 May 2004 | 16 May 2004 | 23 May 2004 | 30 May 2004 | 06 June 2004 | 13 June 2004 | 20 June 2004 | 27 June 2004 | 04 July 2004 | 11 July 2004 | 18 July 2004 | 25 July 2004 | 01 August 2004 | 08 August 2004 | 15 August 2004 | 22 August 2004 | 29 August 2004 | 05 September 2004 | 12 September 2004 | 19 September 2004 | 26 September 2004 | 10 October 2004 | 17 October 2004 | 24 October 2004 | 31 October 2004 | 07 November 2004 | 14 November 2004 | 21 November 2004 | 28 November 2004 | 05 December 2004 | 12 December 2004 | 19 December 2004 | 26 December 2004 | 02 January 2005 | 09 January 2005 | 16 January 2005 | 23 January 2005 | 30 January 2005 | 06 February 2005 | 13 February 2005 | 20 February 2005 | 27 February 2005 | 06 March 2005 | 13 March 2005 | 20 March 2005 | 27 March 2005 | 03 April 2005 | 10 April 2005 | 17 April 2005 | 24 April 2005 | 01 May 2005 | 08 May 2005 | 15 May 2005 | 22 May 2005 | 29 May 2005 | 05 June 2005 | 19 June 2005 | 26 June 2005 | 03 July 2005 | 10 July 2005 | 17 July 2005 | 24 July 2005 | 31 July 2005 | 07 August 2005 | 14 August 2005 | 21 August 2005 | 28 August 2005 | 04 September 2005 | 11 September 2005 | 18 September 2005 | 25 September 2005 | 02 October 2005 | 09 October 2005 | 16 October 2005 | 23 October 2005 | 30 October 2005 | 06 November 2005 | 13 November 2005 | 20 November 2005 | 27 November 2005 | 04 December 2005 | 11 December 2005 | 18 December 2005 | 25 December 2005 | 01 January 2006 | 08 January 2006 | 15 January 2006 | 22 January 2006 | 29 January 2006 | 05 February 2006 | 12 February 2006 | 19 February 2006 | 26 February 2006 | 05 March 2006 | 12 March 2006 | 19 March 2006 | 26 March 2006 | 02 April 2006 | 09 April 2006 | 16 April 2006 | 23 April 2006 | 30 April 2006 | 07 May 2006 | 14 May 2006 | 21 May 2006 | 28 May 2006 | 04 June 2006 | 11 June 2006 | 18 June 2006 | 25 June 2006 | 02 July 2006 | 09 July 2006 | 23 July 2006 | 30 July 2006 | 06 August 2006 | 13 August 2006 | 20 August 2006 | 27 August 2006 | 03 September 2006 | 10 September 2006 | 17 September 2006 | 24 September 2006 | 22 October 2006 | 29 October 2006 | 05 November 2006 | 12 November 2006 | 19 November 2006 | 26 November 2006 | 03 December 2006 | 10 December 2006 | 17 December 2006 | 24 December 2006 | 31 December 2006 | 07 January 2007 | 14 January 2007 | 21 January 2007 | 28 January 2007 | 04 February 2007 | 11 February 2007 | 18 February 2007 | 25 February 2007 | 04 March 2007 | 11 March 2007 | 18 March 2007 | 25 March 2007 | 01 April 2007 | 08 April 2007 | 15 April 2007 | 22 April 2007 | 29 April 2007 | 06 May 2007 | 13 May 2007 | 20 May 2007 | 27 May 2007 | 03 June 2007 | 10 June 2007 | 17 June 2007 | 24 June 2007 | 01 July 2007 | 08 July 2007 | 15 July 2007 | 22 July 2007 | 05 August 2007 | 12 August 2007 | 19 August 2007 | 26 August 2007 | 02 September 2007 | 09 September 2007 | 16 September 2007 | 23 September 2007 | 30 September 2007 | 07 October 2007 | 14 October 2007 | 21 October 2007 | 28 October 2007 | 04 November 2007 | 11 November 2007 | 18 November 2007 | 25 November 2007 | 02 December 2007 | 09 December 2007 | 16 December 2007 | 23 December 2007 | 30 December 2007 | 06 January 2008 | 13 January 2008 | 20 January 2008 | 27 January 2008 |


Find any AiT/Planet Lar publication at your nearest comic store.

Can't find it at your local retailer? Get it online at Khepri.com